India's news, as it happens

Live TV
Business

Mumbai ITAT rules redevelopment payment is capital gains, not other income

The tribunal granted a taxpayer relief after the Income Tax Department denied her Section 54EC exemption on a Rs 50 lakh receipt.

The Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled in favour of a Mumbai woman, holding that a Rs 50 lakh payment received for redevelopment rights is taxable as capital gains. According to a report by The Times of India, the tribunal overturned previous decisions that had classified the amount as income from other sources.

The woman received the Rs 50 lakh from a property developer under a redevelopment agreement. She subsequently invested the amount in Rural Electrification Corporation (REC) bonds to claim an exemption under Section 54EC of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

The Income Tax Department had denied the exemption, treating the receipt as income from other sources and adding it to her total income. The Assessing Officer reasoned that because the owners retained rights to the property and would receive premises in the redeveloped building, the non-refundable payment was not capital gains.

The ITAT ruled that development rights qualify as a capital asset. The tribunal observed that the payment was not a gratuitous receipt but was intrinsically connected to the rights parted with by the owner in favour of the developer.

The tribunal stated that the transfer of such valuable rights constitutes the transfer of a capital asset, even if the owners do not sell the entire land or building. It directed the Assessing Officer to assess the amount under capital gains and allow the Section 54EC exemption, subject to verification of statutory conditions.

Spotted a mistake? Tell us

More in Business

All Business news