India's news, as it happens

Live TV
Crime

Delhi Police tell Supreme Court reel-makers cannot claim journalist protections

Key points card: Police argued influencers are not equivalent to professional journalists; Submission made by Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar; Petitioners alleged journalists were harassed during protests against CEC.
Key points from the story. As reported by The Pioneer, Moneycontrol, Telegraph India.

The police argued that social media influencers and content creators should not be treated as equivalent to professional journalists during protests.

The Delhi Police has informed the Supreme Court that social media influencers and reel-makers are not entitled to the same protections as journalists covering protests. In a counter-affidavit, the police stated that content creators cannot automatically claim the rights extended to professional journalists during demonstrations.

The submission was made by Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar in response to petitions filed by the Network of Women in Media, India, Free Speech Collective, Delhi Union of Journalists, and Kerala Union of Working Journalists. The petitioners alleged that journalists were harassed, manhandled, and detained while covering protests against Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar in Delhi.

According to reports from The Pioneer and Telegraph India, the police argued that it was difficult for officers to distinguish between professional reporters and individuals using cameras and microphones to create content for platforms like YouTube. The affidavit questioned if those making reels for commercial gain should be categorised as journalists or reporters, suggesting that the intent behind the activity might be a decisive factor.

The police maintained that an October 11 Supreme Court order, which assured that professionals would not be hindered in their duties, was intended for legitimate journalistic work. They argued this does not exempt influencers or unruly protesters from following lawful instructions at prohibited assemblies.

Defending an October 5 advisory, the police said media personnel should display identity cards from their organisations or the Press Information Bureau (PIB). However, they clarified that lacking PIB accreditation does not disqualify someone from being recognised as a journalist if they hold employer-issued cards.

Spotted a mistake? Tell us

Related stories

More in Crime

All Crime news