India's news, as it happens

Live TV
Economy

Mumbai tribunal allows Section 54 exemption despite missing original tax return

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal ruled that taxpayers can claim capital gains exemptions during reassessment proceedings even if they did not file an initial return.

The Mumbai bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has ruled that a taxpayer can claim a Section 54 exemption for reinvesting capital gains into a new house, even if they failed to file an original income tax return. According to a report by the Times of India, the tribunal held that such claims can be considered during reassessment proceedings.

The case involved an individual who did not submit an income tax return under Section 139(1) for the 2017-18 assessment year. After the Income Tax Department identified a property purchase worth Rs 45 lakh, proceedings were initiated under Section 147, and a notice was issued on March 24, 2024.

In response to the notice, the man filed a return on April 4, 2024, claiming a Rs 49 lakh exemption under Section 54 for capital gains from a residential property sale. However, the assessing officer rejected the claim because no original return had been filed, adding Rs 31,38,256 to his income.

The Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) upheld this decision, citing a Supreme Court judgment regarding limits on claims during reassessment. The ITAT Mumbai clarified that because the capital gains were the very income that escaped assessment, the exemption claim was directly relevant to calculating that income.

The tribunal noted that filing a return by the prescribed due date is not a mandatory condition for Section 54. It also observed that the assessing officer had previously accepted a similar deduction for the man's wife regarding the same investment.

The ITAT overturned the previous orders and remanded the case to the assessing officer. The officer has been directed to re-evaluate the taxpayer's entitlement to the Section 54 exemption on its merits.

Spotted a mistake? Tell us

More in Economy

All Economy news