Ohio jury awards $1.65 million to residents over lost tree buffer
A group of Pierce Township neighbours won damages after a company removed trees meant to shield homes from coal-ash ponds.
A US jury has awarded $1,654,080 to residents of Pierce Township after approximately 250 trees were removed during the demolition of a former coal-fired power plant. According to the Times of India, the verdict was announced on Wednesday following two and a half hours of deliberation.
The lawsuit was filed in 2019 by the local group Neighbors Opposing Pit Expansion (NOPE). The group alleged that Commercial Liability Partners (CLP), which purchased the 1,443-acre site of the former William C. Beckjord power plant in 2018, violated an agreement to preserve a greenbelt intended to separate homes from coal-ash ponds near the Ohio River.
Residents testified that logging equipment destroyed a mature forest containing pine, walnut, cherry, and maple trees. They stated the removal of the trees, some reaching 50 feet in height, damaged the environment, reduced wildlife, and allowed invasive honeysuckle to spread.
CLP disputed the claims and questioned the $3.3 million in damages sought by the residents. A lawyer for the company argued that the compensation demand was unreasonable and noted a lack of photographs showing the greenbelt's condition prior to the logging.
The jury's award includes $1,142,860 for replacing 233 trees, $102,000 for invasive species removal, $28,600 for land revegetation, and $160,620 for sapling care. A separate dispute regarding the disclosure of coal-ash handling is still awaiting a jury trial.
