India's news, as it happens

Live TV
World

Arizona appeals court allows lawsuit against HOA over backyard gate

The court rejected an attempt by a homeowners' association to force a family into private arbitration regarding a gate replacement request.

An Arizona appeals court has rejected an attempt by the Wigwam Creek South Community Association to force a couple into private arbitration, according to a report by the Times of India. The ruling allows a lawsuit filed by Kevin and Jennifer LoPresto to proceed in court.

The LoPrestos sought permission to replace a single backyard gate with a wider double gate to allow their disabled son to park his golf cart in the backyard. The association denied the November 2024 request, leading the couple to file a lawsuit in April 2025.

The couple accused the association of failing to act fairly and breaching contract duties. They argued the association failed to enforce community rules impartially and without selective enforcement.

The association argued that the dispute must be settled through private arbitration based on the community's Declaration of Covenants, Conditions and Restrictions and its Guidelines for Community Living. However, the Arizona Court of Appeals issued a memorandum decision on September 25, 2026, stating the arbitration rules were one-sided and unenforceable.

The court found that while homeowners were required to use arbitration, the association was excused from the same requirement and could still use the court system. The judges granted the LoPrestos reasonable legal fees and court costs related to the appeal.

Spotted a mistake? Tell us

More in World

All World news